mystery box surprise best sellers

#1 Cute Cryptids Series TeeTurtle Cute Cryptids Series Reversible Plushie Mystery Box - 3-Inch Mini Two-Sided Blind Box Plush with Embroidered Details - Cute Collectible Surprise Toy for Kids, Teens, and Adults

$6.40 on Amazon

#2 The Boxcar Children Mysteries The Boxcar Children Mysteries Boxed Set 1-4: The Boxcar Children; Surprise Island; The Yellow House; Mystery Ranch

$15 on Amazon

#3 🔥 Pop! Advent Calendar Funko Pop! Advent Calendar: Five Night At Freddy's (FNAF) - 24 Days of Surprises - Collectible Vinyl Mini Figures - Mystery Box - Gift Idea - Holiday Present for Kids - Christmas Countdown

$54.99 on Amazon

#4 🔥 Squishmallows Original Squishmallows: Original 5" Plush Mystery Box - 5 Pack - Surprise Assorted Character Styles, Soft & Squishy, Stuffed Animals, Collectible Toy, Kids 3+

$19.18 on Walmart

#5 🔥 Skibidi Toilet Giant Skibidi Toilet Giant Mystery Loot Box, With 20 Mystery Surprises, YouTube Animation Sensation, Exclusive Mystery Figures, Officially Licensed Skibidi Toilet Merch

$74.88 on Walmart

#6 Stitch Jumbo Mystery Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 10 Surprises Inside, Collectible Figures and Plush, Blind Box, Toy for Fans, Boys, Girls, Kids Ages 3 and up

$21 on Walmart

#7 Asian candy mystery gift UNHA'S ASIAN SNACK BOX Asian candy mystery gift box, 60 count variety pack of Japanese and Korean treats, sweet sampler of chewy, fruity, and chocolate snacks, fun surprise box for kids, teens, and candy lovers

$16.99 on Amazon

#8 🔥 🆕 Doll Advent Calendar Doll Advent Calendar - 24 Days of Surprises - Collectible Vinyl Mini Figures - Mystery Box - Gift Idea - Holiday Present for Kids - Christmas Countdown

$27.97 on Walmart

#9 🔥 🆕 Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 10 Surprises Inside, Collectible Figures and Plush, Blind Box, Toy for Fans, Boys, Girls, Kids Ages 3 and Up by Just Play

$21 on Amazon

#10 Pop! Bitty Countdown Funko Pop! Bitty Countdown Calendar: Disney Princess - 24 Days of Surprises - Collectible Vinyl Mini Figures - Mystery Box - Gift Idea - Holiday Present for Kids - Christmas or Birthday Countdown

$29.49 on Amazon

#11 🆕 Cheryl's Cookies Cookie Cheryl's Cookies Cookie Gift Box w/ 12 Surprise Mystery, Assorted Buttercream Frosted Sugar Cookies, Individually Wrapped, Gourmet, Handmade, Any Occasion, Birthday, Family, Friends, Loved Ones

$19.99 on Walmart

#12 🔥 🆕 24pcs Littlest Pet Shop 24pcs Littlest Pet Shop Christmas Gift Littlest Pet Shop Advent Calendar 24 Days Of Surprises - Collectible Figure - Mystery Box - Gift Idea - Holiday Present Christmas Countdown B

$17.29 on Walmart

#13 🔥 🆕 GOANDO Fishing Lures GOANDO Fishing Lures 2025 Advent Calendar Christmas Countdown Lure Baits Mystery Tackle Box- 24 Days of Surprises for Fisher Adult Men Teen Boys

$19.43 on Walmart

#14 Cookie Gift Box w/ 12 Cheryl's Cookies® Cookie Gift Box w/ 12 Surprise Mystery, Assorted Buttercream Frosted Sugar Cookies, Individually Wrapped, Gourmet, Handmade, Any Occasion, Birthday, Family, Friends, Loved Ones

$19.99 on Amazon

#15 🔥 🆕 24pcs Littlest Pet Shop 24pcs Littlest Pet Shop Merch Littlest Pet Shop Advent Calendar 24 Days Of Surprises - Collectible Figure - Mystery Box - Gift Idea - Holiday Present Christmas Countdown A

$25.54 on Walmart

#16 🔥 LEGO F1 Collectible Race LEGO F1 Collectible Race Cars, 6 Pack - Building Set for Boys & Girls, Ages 6+ - Birthday Party Favor or Gift - Mystery Box W/ Surprise F1 Car Toys - Travel Toys for Kids - 66796

$39.99 on Walmart

#17 🔥 Squishmallow Official Squishmallow Official Kellytoy Plush 5" Plush Mystery Box Three Pack - Styles Will Vary in Surprise 5" Plush Box That Includes Three 5" Plush

$26.99 on Walmart

#18 🔥 🆕 Pickleball 60 Years 2D Pickleball 60 Years 2D Christmas Advent Calendar Daily Surprises 24 Pairs Blind Box Mystery Collectible Toy Set Xmas Tree Ornaments Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$18.98 on Walmart

#19 🔥 🆕 Christmas Alabama Crimson Christmas Alabama Crimson Tide 2D Advent Calendar Mystery Collectible Toy Set Daily Surprises Xmas Tree Ornaments 24 Pairs Blind Box Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$12.99 on Walmart

#20 🔥 Christmas Wicked 2D Advent Christmas Wicked 2D Advent Calendar Daily Surprises Xmas Tree Ornaments 24 Pairs Blind Box Mystery Collectible Toy Set Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$17.84 on Walmart