mystery surprise toys best sellers

#1 SCRUFFALUVS Pink Surprise SCRUFF-A-LUVS SCRUFFALUVS Pink Surprise Pet, Mystery Plush Toys, Stuffed Animals, Wash to Reveal 1 of 3 Rescue Pets: Puppy, Bunny, or Kitty - Includes 8.7" Deluxe Pet Carrier - Styles May Vary

$17.49 on Amazon

#2 Cute Cryptids Series TeeTurtle Cute Cryptids Series Reversible Plushie Mystery Box - 3-Inch Mini Two-Sided Blind Box Plush with Embroidered Details - Cute Collectible Surprise Toy for Kids, Teens, and Adults

$6.40 on Amazon

#3 My Mini Baby Series 2 5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2 by ZURU, Collectible Mystery Capsule, Toy for Girls, Realistic Miniature Baby, Playset and Accessories (Single Capsule)

$9.97 on Amazon

#4 Winter Besties Collector Littlest Pet Shop - Winter Besties Collector Set - LPS Gen 7, Authentic Mystery Figures, Surprise Collectible Kidult Toy, Girls, Boys, Kids, Tweens Ages 4+

$19.99 on Amazon

#5 My Mini Baby Series 2 5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2 by ZURU, Collectible Mystery Capsule, Toy for Girls, Realistic Miniature Baby, Playset and Accessories (2 Capsules)

$19.97 on Amazon

#6 Alive Mystery Hatch Hatchimals Alive, Mystery Hatch Draggle, Surprise Interactive Toy & Egg with Mist, Lights & Sounds (Styles May Vary), Gifts & Stocking Stuffers for Girls & Boys

$39.99 on Amazon

#7 🔥 Squishmallows Original Squishmallows: Original 5" Plush Mystery Box - 5 Pack - Surprise Assorted Character Styles, Soft & Squishy, Stuffed Animals, Collectible Toy, Kids 3+

$19.18 on Walmart

#8 Hot Wheels Mystery Models Hot Wheels Mystery Models Surprise Toy Car or Truck in 1:64 Scale (Styles May Vary)

$1.24 on Walmart

#9 6 Pack 3D Printed Dragon Rapean 6 Pack 3D Printed Dragon Eggs with Dragon Inside Easter Basket Stuffers, Mini Mystery Crystal Easter Toys, Home Desk Decor Surprise Gift 3D Printed Animals Fidget Toys

$22.97 on Amazon

#10 Stitch Jumbo Mystery Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 10 Surprises Inside, Collectible Figures and Plush, Blind Box, Toy for Fans, Boys, Girls, Kids Ages 3 and up

$21 on Walmart

#11 🔥 🆕 Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 10 Surprises Inside, Collectible Figures and Plush, Blind Box, Toy for Fans, Boys, Girls, Kids Ages 3 and Up by Just Play

$21 on Amazon

#12 Minifigures Series 25 Lego Minifigures Series 25 Collectible Figures, Surprise Adventure Toy Building Set for Independent Play, Gift Idea for Boys, Mystery Figures, Girls and Kids Aged 5 Years Old and Up, 71045

$11.89 on Amazon

#13 3D Printed Dragon Eggs UXBSTM 3D Printed Dragon Eggs with Dragon Inside, Mystery Crystal Dragon Easter Egg Fillers Toys, Articulated Fidget 3D Printed Animals, Surprise Gift, Christmas Toy 2025

$15.99 on Amazon

#14 🔥 LEGO F1 Collectible Race LEGO F1 Collectible Race Cars, 6 Pack - Building Set for Boys & Girls, Ages 6+ - Birthday Party Favor or Gift - Mystery Box W/ Surprise F1 Car Toys - Travel Toys for Kids - 66796

$39.99 on Walmart

#15 Ryan's World Mini Mystery Ryan's World Mini Mystery Egg with 4 Surprise Toys Inside for Ages 3+

$8.99 on Walmart

#16 3D Printed Dragon Egg 3D Printed Dragon Egg, Mystery Crystal Dragon Egg Fidget Toys Surprise, Easter Eggs Mythical Dragon Eggs with Dragon Inside, Full Articulated Dragon Crystal Dragon in Egg

$6.36 on Walmart

#17 🔥 🆕 Pickleball 60 Years 2D Pickleball 60 Years 2D Christmas Advent Calendar Daily Surprises 24 Pairs Blind Box Mystery Collectible Toy Set Xmas Tree Ornaments Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$18.98 on Walmart

#18 🔥 🆕 Christmas Alabama Crimson Christmas Alabama Crimson Tide 2D Advent Calendar Mystery Collectible Toy Set Daily Surprises Xmas Tree Ornaments 24 Pairs Blind Box Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$12.99 on Walmart

#19 🔥 2D Boston Red Sox Christmas 2D Boston Red Sox Christmas Advent Calendar Funny Decorations Mystery Collectible Toy Set Daily Surprises Xmas Tree Ornaments Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$12.89 on Walmart

#20 🔥 Christmas Wicked 2D Advent Christmas Wicked 2D Advent Calendar Daily Surprises Xmas Tree Ornaments 24 Pairs Blind Box Mystery Collectible Toy Set Birthday Festival Gifts for Children

$17.84 on Walmart