mystery toys best sellers

#1 SCRUFFALUVS Pink Surprise SCRUFF-A-LUVS SCRUFFALUVS Pink Surprise Pet, Mystery Plush Toys, Stuffed Animals, Wash to Reveal 1 of 3 Rescue Pets: Puppy, Bunny, or Kitty - Includes 8.7" Deluxe Pet Carrier - Styles May Vary

$17.49 on Amazon

#2 Cute Cryptids Series TeeTurtle Cute Cryptids Series Reversible Plushie Mystery Box - 3-Inch Mini Two-Sided Blind Box Plush with Embroidered Details - Cute Collectible Surprise Toy for Kids, Teens, and Adults

$6.40 on Amazon

#3 Squishies Kids DIY Activity Elmer's Squishies, Kids DIY Activity Kit, Squishy Glow in the Dark Toys, Creates 2 Mystery Characters, 13 Piece Set - Slime Fun, Crafts, Holiday Gift for Ages 6+

$9.89 on Amazon

#4 My Mini Baby Series 2 5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2 by ZURU, Collectible Mystery Capsule, Toy for Girls, Realistic Miniature Baby, Playset and Accessories (Single Capsule)

$9.97 on Amazon

#5 🔥 Books Capsule by ZURU Mini Brands Books Capsule by ZURU Real Miniature Book Brands Collectible Toy, Capsules of 5 Mystery Miniature Books with Real readable Pages and Accessories for Kids, Teens, Adults (Single Capsule)

$9.99 on Amazon

#6 Mysteries Beach Detectives Barbie Mysteries: Beach Detectives Playset with Beach Buggy Toy Car & 10+ Accessories, Including Beach Chair & Towel

$19.97 on Amazon

#7 🔥 Mystery Egg Puzzle Box GALAPOPO Mystery Egg Puzzle Box, Money Puzzle Box for Cash Gift, Birthday Wedding Easter Xmas Holiday Celebration Money Gift Ideas, Brain Teaser Puzzle Toy for Adults Kids Teens

$12.99 on Amazon

#8 Winter Besties Collector Littlest Pet Shop - Winter Besties Collector Set - LPS Gen 7, Authentic Mystery Figures, Surprise Collectible Kidult Toy, Girls, Boys, Kids, Tweens Ages 4+

$19.99 on Amazon

#9 My Mini Baby Series 2 5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2 by ZURU, Collectible Mystery Capsule, Toy for Girls, Realistic Miniature Baby, Playset and Accessories (2 Capsules)

$19.97 on Amazon

#10 Alive Mystery Hatch Hatchimals Alive, Mystery Hatch Draggle, Surprise Interactive Toy & Egg with Mist, Lights & Sounds (Styles May Vary), Gifts & Stocking Stuffers for Girls & Boys

$39.99 on Amazon

#11 Magic Potion Kit for GORISPI Magic Potion Kit for Girls - Fairy Potions Kit 22 Potions Magic Mix Kit for Kids 6 7 8 9 10 12+ Years Mystery Potion Making kit Art Craft Kit Gifts Toys for Christmas Halloween Birthday

$16.99 on Amazon

#12 🔥 Squishmallows Original Squishmallows: Original 5" Plush Mystery Box - 5 Pack - Surprise Assorted Character Styles, Soft & Squishy, Stuffed Animals, Collectible Toy, Kids 3+

$19.18 on Walmart

#13 Hot Wheels Mystery Models Hot Wheels Mystery Models Surprise Toy Car or Truck in 1:64 Scale (Styles May Vary)

$1.24 on Walmart

#14 LEGO Minifigures Spider Man LEGO Minifigures Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse - Mystery Box with 1 of 12 Kids Toys for Pretend Play - Super Hero Action Figures for Boys & Girls, Ages 5+ - GIft Idea for Birthdays - 71050

$4.97 on Walmart

#15 🔥 Fidget Box for Girls FUN KIDZ Fidget Box for Girls Boys, FunKidz Mystery Sensory Fidget Pack Toys for Stress Relief Kids Party Favors Gift Classroom Prizes Travel Camping with Portable Case

$19.19 on Amazon

#16 TOYZERO Lulu The Piggy TOYZERO + TOYZERO+ Lulu The Piggy Blind Box Figures - Puppet Show Series Plush Keychain Blind Boxes Figurines Finger Puppet Toy Cute Stuffed Animals Mystery Box Collectible Decorations Birthday Gift, Single Box

$15.99 on Amazon

#17 🔥 Barbie Mysteries The Barbie Mysteries: The Great Horse Chase Stable Playset with Doll & Toy Horse 25-piece Set

$89.99 on Walmart

#18 6 Pack 3D Printed Dragon Rapean 6 Pack 3D Printed Dragon Eggs with Dragon Inside Easter Basket Stuffers, Mini Mystery Crystal Easter Toys, Home Desk Decor Surprise Gift 3D Printed Animals Fidget Toys

$22.97 on Amazon

#19 Gift Fidget Box Toys FUN KIDZ Gift Fidget Box Toys Pack for Kids 3-12, FunKidz Sensory Toys for Boys Girls Age 7-12 Autistic Children in Mystery Storage Portable Box

$23.99 on Amazon

#20 The Monsters Almost Hidden POP MART The Monsters Almost Hidden Series Blind Box Figures, Random Design Mystery Toys for Modern Home Decor, Collectible Toy Set for Desk Accessories, Single Box

$19.99 on Amazon